Loyalty in 2025 is no longer just “spend and earn.” The brands winning today make points feel effortless, trust feel visible through reviews, and influence feel earned through real creators. Here’s what’s working, what’s fading, and how modern loyalty actually retains customers.
At Bernstein-Rein, we believe retail intelligence comes from consumer insights, a true brand purpose, and half a century of unrivaled experience. We put these beliefs together to accelerate growth. This approach is called Retailigent™ – it's what drives our work every day.
If loyalty programs were once a simple trade—“buy more, earn points, get discount”—they’re now competing with a much noisier world. Consumers are juggling dozens of memberships, apps, and reward currencies. At the same time, they’re leaning harder on reviews and creators to decide where to spend. So, what’s actually driving loyalty today: points, peer proof, or influencer pull?
Let’s dig into what’s working, what’s fading, and what brands should do next.
Yes… but only when points don’t feel like homework.
Traditional “spend X, earn Y” programs still matter, but the winners are shifting points from transactional to motivational. Industry reports for 2025 flag gamification and experience-based rewards as top growth levers, with nearly half of brands calling them the most urgent investments. That lines up with what consumers show us: they’ll chase points when the chase is fun, visible, and fast.
Think of the current leaders:
What’s not working? Points that expire quickly, require huge thresholds, or only unlock discounts you can find elsewhere. In other words, points are still powerful—when they feel like a shortcut, not a chore.
They will—but brands need to earn that home-screen spot.
App-based loyalty is still expanding, fueled by models like cashback, receipt scanning, and low-friction points that turn saving into a daily habit. The “download for a coupon” pitch works best when the app becomes more than a wallet: a companion.
What’s working in apps right now:
What’s failing: apps that exist only to push promos. If the experience is clunky, irrelevant, or clearly data-grabby, consumers churn fast. In a world where people are increasingly anxious about privacy and automation, trust and utility matter more than ever.
Bottom line: the app stays when it simplifies life or builds identity, not when it’s just a digital coupon drawer.
Loyalty doesn’t begin at redemption. It begins at belief.
In 2025, reviews are still the clearest trust signal consumers have:
That’s huge. It means reviews are effectively the “first touchpoint” of loyalty. If your program promises VIP treatment but your reviews say shipping is slow or customer service ghosts people, points won’t save you.
What brands should do:
A great loyalty program amplifies a great experience. Reviews reveal whether you actually have one.
Influencers still drive discovery and conversion, but the type of influence that works has changed.
The influencer economy is growing, with global spend projected to hit $32.55B in 2025 and over 80% of marketers saying it’s effective. But consumers are becoming more selective about who they trust. Reports show a clear shift toward nano- and micro-influencers and toward long-term partnerships that feel real, not rented. (Influencer Marketing Hub)
What’s working:
What’s not:
Influence builds loyalty when it deepens connection, not when it manufactures hype.
Winning loyalty in 2025 is a three-part equation:
1. Make points feel like progress.
Gamify, personalize, and offer rewards that matter emotionally (Open Loyalty).
2. Make trust visible.
Reviews are your loyalty program’s truth serum. Invest in experience, then showcase proof (DemandSage).
3. Make influence feel earned.
Prioritize credible creators and sustained relationships over bursts of buzz (Influencer Marketing Hub).
Consumers are still loyal. They’re just no longer loyal to systems—they’re loyal to brands that feel worth returning to. Points, apps, reviews, and influencers are all tools. The brands winning now are the ones using those tools to build a relationship, not a rewards spreadsheet.
Review how today’s top brands are building repeat customers in a world where points alone aren’t enough. From frictionless rewards and app-driven value to the trust power of reviews and the pull of authentic creators, we help break down the strategies that actually move behavior. Dive in to learn what’s working, what’s not, and how to design loyalty that customers choose—again and again.
